Comments on: About Tanmatra, the Malayalam movie https://smrti.sayana.in/archives/19 Tue, 14 Mar 2006 18:11:10 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.7.15 By: jiit https://smrti.sayana.in/archives/19/comment-page-1#comment-50 Tue, 14 Mar 2006 18:11:10 +0000 http://smrti.sayana.in/?p=19#comment-50 let me clarify my comparison with thalavattam:

The fact that Priyadarshan-mohanlal combination was responsible for the resurrection of Nair supremacy and tharavad centeredness in Kerala movies is a well known.
Although he always enjoys good box offices for his movies, Priyan’s stature as ‘special’ movie maker is virtually nonexistent, possibly because of his day-light robbery of foreign movie themes. So thalavatttom was never a critically acclaimed movie. The movie, while hovering around the tharavad nostalgia (nedumudi venu’s character and his relationship with mohanlal), do (mis)handle a group
of patients in a mental asylum.

Blessy does the same thing in thanmathra. The difference
here is the support from the critics. The media gives him
the tag of the most promising director.

In a nutshell, although both these directors are one and
the same, the status they enjoy in the malayalam cinema is different. While priyan maintains his position was a ‘popular’ director for the masses, Blessy enjoys a seat
among the ‘parallel’ directors of malayalam movies.

]]>
By: smrti https://smrti.sayana.in/archives/19/comment-page-1#comment-35 Fri, 10 Mar 2006 05:06:55 +0000 http://smrti.sayana.in/?p=19#comment-35 Interesting.
But I didnt quite get what jiit means in comparing “talavattom” and “tanmatra”. It would be helpful if you can elaborate.

As an aside, I think there has recently been quite a remarkable move towards what Rat says reclaiming of the feudal and patriarchal essence of samskarika keralam. The nostalgia for a nalukettu architecture, obviously in opposition to the concrete shelter of the Gulf returned, for example. I’m sure it is not just the comfort of the structure that makes naalukettu appealing…….

]]>
By: rat https://smrti.sayana.in/archives/19/comment-page-1#comment-33 Thu, 09 Mar 2006 18:27:41 +0000 http://smrti.sayana.in/?p=19#comment-33 “Its all about returning to mother’s womb”, a comment that I heard while coming out of the plush multiplex in the city suburb. But the film thanmathra, for me, was all about returning to nair tharavad. The movie reclaims all the feudal and patriarchal ‘essence’ of samskarika keralam. The film relentlessly talks the nostalgic memories of the tharavad and its high culture. These nostalgic constructions always require the essential, ‘inferior’ other – in the form of manipulating ministers (muslim characters), gulf-returned, ‘low cultured’ neighbor (christians) and the money minded and tharikida Joseph. Thanmathra is a well-composed movie for projecting all these factors.

]]>
By: jiit https://smrti.sayana.in/archives/19/comment-page-1#comment-32 Thu, 09 Mar 2006 17:53:57 +0000 http://smrti.sayana.in/?p=19#comment-32 Sad, Blessy could not grow up from the typical malayalee filmy cliché of – muslims, darks, poola achayans, tamil villains conspiring against the ‘cultural supremacy’ of high castes of menons and nairs. Each minute of the movie provides ample testimony to that. I don’t find this movie anyway different from one of Priyadarshan’s movies – Thalavattom.

Since I have no detailed clinical information on Alzheimer’s disease, I can not comment on the way Belssy had portrayed the patient – a man getting the disease in the morning, turning to a full scale mental patient by evening and dying a week after !!!

One thing is sure; this Padmarajan disciple is nowhere nearer to his mentor’s class and vision.

]]>
By: smrti https://smrti.sayana.in/archives/19/comment-page-1#comment-29 Sun, 05 Mar 2006 04:14:24 +0000 http://smrti.sayana.in/?p=19#comment-29 Well, ‘hate’ could be too strong a word..Yes, I also read quite a number of positive reviews as well…Let me see, I’ll ask my friends themselves to write why they didnt like the movie.

]]>
By: Manu https://smrti.sayana.in/archives/19/comment-page-1#comment-28 Sat, 04 Mar 2006 17:35:09 +0000 http://smrti.sayana.in/?p=19#comment-28 Not sure Y otherpeople hated it.I enjoyed this movie. If nothing, this was a refreshing experience after the lean patch in malayalam film industry. Something reminding the old padmarajan/bharathan era ( uppolam varilla uppilittathu, ennalum). Me also curoius to know the other side of it.

]]>